ANTONESCU : PRO sau CONTRA

ANTONESCU : PRO sau CONTRA

ion antonescu

Unii spun ca a fost salvatorul unei intregi natiuni…altii il condamna de genocid. Tu ce parere ai?

Poti sa iti argumentezi parerea.

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “ANTONESCU : PRO sau CONTRA

  1. “His cowardice caused him to first side with the Nazis and then later, when losing against the Russians, he tried to make an alliance with the Allied powers.”

    i would study more history before making this kind of sentences…

    Like

  2. The problem is that every country records a different history. I’m sure what Romanian students are taught is completely different than what people in the rest of the world learn. Just as my American version of history differs other countries. Atonescu is is portrayed as a bumbling, cowardly psychopath. That he took it upon himself to initiate pogroms against the Jews and Roma was enough to get him convicted and his part in the Odessa Massacre was enough to get him shot. His cowardice caused him to first side with the Nazis and then later, when losing against the Russians, he tried to make an alliance with the Allied powers. I think in Romania he is portrayed as some sort of hero. Before Romanians tell me that I am a stupid American who knows nothing, I would offer a comparable story. This is a story of a leader who was involved in a civil war. He knew that the rebels would win, so he allowed his generals to burn farms, kill livestock, kill civilians, etc in an attempt to win the war. His brutal tactics worked and the rebels were eventually defeated. Most Americans know this man as a hero, Abraham Lincoln. He is even on our $5 bill. Yet to those of us who are descendants of those rebels, we view him a war criminal. As I said, we all have different views of history. Who is right and who is wrong? Ask the dead, they know.

    Like

  3. Iar referitor la perceptia sa (a Maresalului) “salvator” sau “autorul de genocid” e greu de spus daca a fost 100% ori una ori cealalta. Personal il consider pe Maresalul Antonescu un om al timpului sau, data fiind situatia geopolitica a acelor vremuri. Luand in considerare eliminarea evreilor si a tiganilor din tara noastra, avand in vedere ca eram sub sfera de influenta a Germaniei, era o obligatie de a executa acest ordin-Doctrinar si ideologic dealtfel.

    Like

  4. E discutabil, adevarul e sigur undeva la mijloc. Problema pricipala e ca lumea nu e informata indeajuns ca sa inteleaga ce a presupus respectiva conjunctura istorica foarte complicata; cu rusii la granita, germania deja pierzand sistematic pe frontul Stalingrad-ului, nu cred ca era alta solutie, rea totusi, decat sa trecem de partea rusilor; aliatii erau deja pe continent; chiar daca am fi ramas aliantii germaniei razboiul tot era pierdut si Antonescu tot ar fi murit executat, nu rezolvam cu nimic situatia doar ca prelungeam condamnarea lui. Multa lume e subiectiva in legatura cu acest subiect, uitand ca la acel moment, de maxima tensiune politica pana la urma am ales raul mai mic. Oricum ajungeam in sfera de influenta a URSS pt ca aliatii nu puteau creea o enclava-“tampon” cu Rusia.
    In acest context este evident ca declaratia vis-a-vis de Maresalul Ion Antonescu si Regele Mihai, a presedintelui, nu este una de luat in considerare. El a preluat cliseele clasice si le-a reprodus, neganding si neaprofundand problema.

    Like

    • Imi puneam intrebarile astea in 2011..acum mi-am dat seama ca e prea greu sa ne facem o parere apropiata de adevar. Daca ne uitam in prezent la jocurile politice, e greu sa distingem adevaruld e minciuna, albul de negru, daramite despre ce s-a intampalt acum zeci de ani.

      Like

Tu ce crezi despre asta?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s